In 1886 Arizona, Jane Johnson runs a failing saloon in the remote town of Green Valley City and dreams of escaping to New York. When she learns that three legendary outlaws each have bounties on their heads, she spreads a false rumor about a railroad being built nearby and puts the saloon up for sale to lure them in. But the three arrive not as real criminals, but as struggling actors impersonating them, and a vengeful gunslinger named Billy enters first, upset by a past family tragedy. With identities exposed and motivations clashing, the situation unravels into a comic chaos of deception, revenge, and accidental alliances. The musical ultimately shifts from a bounty plot to a story of found purpose and new beginnings.