Sweeney Todd's roots are in the penny dreadful: a one-penny serial that held readers with murder, revenge, plots and twists. The String of Pearls was staged before its ending was even published, and by the 1870s most of Britain knew Todd.
The musical keeps every ingredient of that pleasure: a wronged man returning under a new name, a wicked judge lusting after a beauty, a girl locked in a tower and the young man who tries to save her, hidden identities and missed meetings. Several of these came from Christopher Bond, whose 1970 play the musical is based on. He borrowed them from The Count of Monte Cristo and Jacobean revenge tragedy.
And it is far less frightening than its reputation. Compared with shows like Evil Dead: The Musical, where fake blood sprays the front rows and the audience wears ponchos, it is mild. What makes it work is the way it laces fear and laughter together. The audience has just watched Sweeney kill, and is still shaken, when Mrs. Lovett and Sweeney close Act One with "A Little Priest": a song about turning people into pie filling, trade by trade, with the clergy, politicians and lawyers first in line. The content is gruesome, yet the wordplay is so sharp that even audience members in those professions end up laughing.
At the 2010 BBC Proms concert for Sondheim's 80th birthday, the orchestra was on stage behind the singers. When Bryn Terfel and Maria Friedman pointed at the fiddle player and the piccolo player as candidates for the pie, the orchestra started laughing — the fiddle player first, the moment she was singled out.
The shaving contest with the fake Italian Pirelli and Mrs. Lovett's seaside daydream in "By the Sea" work the same way. You shiver and laugh at the same time; that is the show's particular flavour. Once the gloomy opening passes and Mrs. Lovett starts flirting with the stony Sweeney, the mood shifts, and by the barber-chair scenes you laugh without guilt.
References
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (Wikipedia)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweeney_Todd:_The_Demon_Barber_of_Fleet_Street
Sweeney Todd 2/2 PROMS 2010 Little Priest (YouTube)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTbT6k52uZ0
BBC Proms to Mark Sondheim's 80th with Terfel, Friedman and Beale (Playbill)
https://playbill.com/article/bbc-proms-to-mark-sondheims-80th-with-terfel-friedman-and-beale-radio-and-tv-broadcast-scheduled-com-167894


